Most wholesale buyers negotiate price, MOQ, lead time and warranty before they sign a custom POS terminal project. Almost none of them ask who owns the injection mold, the stamping die or the die-cast tool — until the day they want to move the product to a second supplier and discover they cannot.
That single unanswered question has ended more sourcing relationships than late shipments ever have. This article sets out what tooling actually is in a POS project, the three ownership models you will meet, the clauses that decide the outcome, and how certification and design rights fit into the same negotiation.
In a POS terminal project, "tooling cost" is not one item. An aluminum housing typically requires three separate tool sets:
Each tool carries its own steel cost, machining hours, electrodes, trial shots and rework. Common quotes for a single aluminum housing tool fall in the USD 2,000–8,000 range, though the number moves quickly with part complexity, cavity count and surface finish requirements. A dual-screen terminal with a custom stand can easily require four or five tools before production begins.
Tooling is also not the same as NRE. Non-recurring engineering covers structure design, PCB layout, firmware adaptation, EMC pre-scan and reliability testing. Some factories bundle both into a single "development fee" line, which makes it impossible to tell later what you paid for — and what you therefore own.
Ask for the tooling invoice to be itemized separately from engineering. A supplier that cannot separate the two has either not costed the project properly or prefers the ambiguity.
| Model | What you pay | Who holds title | Typical use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Factory-owned | Amortized into unit price or a small one-off fee | Factory | Catalog-adjacent variants, low volume |
| Customer-owned | Full tool cost, invoiced separately | Buyer | Private-label programs, committed volume |
| Shared or amortized | Partial payment plus per-unit surcharge | Disputed unless written | Pilot programs, uncertain volume |
The amortized model is where disputes are born. The buyer believes that paying a tooling surcharge on every unit buys ownership; the factory treats the surcharge as a financing fee and keeps the tool. Write it down, or assume you own nothing.
Ownership must be stated explicitly, and each tool should be marked for identification — a customer part number engraved or tagged on the mold base. Unmarked tools are the ones that quietly get reallocated to another buyer’s project.
Ownership without possession is a certificate, not an asset. The agreement needs a delivery obligation: on termination, or after a defined period of inactivity, the tool must be released to the buyer or a nominated third party within a stated number of days, in a condition fit for continued production. Specify who pays freight and who hands over the tool history and process sheets.
Tools wear. Define who maintains them, at whose cost, and after how many shots a refurbishment counts as the factory’s responsibility rather than a change order. Without this clause, a worn die becomes a convenient reason to quote a brand-new tool.
If your program pauses, the tool still occupies floor space. Agree a free storage window, a storage fee beyond it, and a clear rule that the tool cannot be scrapped without written notice and a reasonable chance to collect it.
When a program ends, an unowned tool can keep producing your design for someone else. A destruction clause backed by photographic evidence is the cheapest insurance in the whole contract.
Buyers often assume that because they paid for the tool, the CE certificate is theirs as well. It is not. A certificate belongs to whoever is named as its holder, and that name is usually the factory’s legal entity.
The practical fix is to have test reports and the technical file issued in a form that survives a supplier change — generic enough to cover the construction, specific enough to be defensible.
Custom enclosures and stands are registrable designs. The question is who files. A factory registering your design in its own name is not necessarily acting in bad faith — it is often simply the path of least resistance — but it converts your investment into their asset.
Decide three things before the first tool is cut:
If your volume does not justify registration, at minimum keep dated design records: signed drawings, 3D files with timestamps, and photographs of the first article. Unregistered rights are weaker, but they are not worthless.
"Exclusive" means nothing until its scope is defined. Four variables matter:
Most factories will grant model exclusivity against a volume commitment and will refuse open-ended territorial exclusivity. That is a reasonable commercial position. What is not reasonable is exclusivity with no remedy attached, which is a courtesy rather than a contract term.
In practice most tooling negotiations begin with the display configuration, because that is what drives the enclosure. A frequent starting point for private-label programs is the 21.5-inch main display paired with a 17.3-inch secondary screen — a configuration that already requires its own bezel tools, stand casting and cable routing, which makes the ownership conversation concrete rather than theoretical.
| Item | What to get in writing |
|---|---|
| Tool list | Every tool named, with part number and cavity count |
| Cost split | Tooling separated from NRE, itemized line by line |
| Title | Ownership clause plus physical marking on each tool |
| Relocation | Release window, condition standard, freight responsibility |
| Maintenance | Wear thresholds and who pays for refurbishment |
| Storage | Free period, fee after, no scrapping without notice |
| Certification | Holder named, technical file access, DoC signatory |
| Design rights | Filing party, cost bearer, enforcement rights |
| Exclusivity | Scope, volume trigger, duration, remedy |
None of this requires a lawyer to draft in full, but all of it requires being asked before the first tool is cut. A supplier that answers these questions directly, in writing, and without hedging is telling you something useful about how the rest of the program will run.
If you are evaluating a custom terminal program — housing, stand, display configuration and certification included — send over the requirements and we will return a tooling breakdown that separates what you own from what you are only renting.